Who wants to read about a middle-aged heroine?

Posted December 16th, 2009 by Charlotte Henley Babb

Traditionally speaking, the audience for science fiction has always been teen-age boys, and for fantasy, both teen-age boys and girls–perhaps explaining the phenomenal success of the Harry Potter novels. Rowling has created an incredibly detailed fantasy world that lies just a step away from the mundane muggle world, a world that is saved seven times by a group of teens.

Yet teenaged readers grow up. Many of them continue to read science fiction and fantasy, if the attendance at the SF conventions I have attended is any evidence. At DragonCon in Atlanta, originally a gaming con, there are lots of younger folk, under 30, but a large proportion is over 40 as well. At DarkoverCon and the recent DiskworldCon, the under-30 crowd was not much in evidence, perhaps due to the lack of excellent blockbuster movies made from Marion Zimmer Bradley and Terry Pratchett’s wonderful books. Why Spielberg, Verbinsky,  and others have not seen the incredible potential in these stories and characters is beyond me. Maybe it’s because the characters are typically NOT teenagers, who after all, are the only people who go to movies, right?

Frodo was over thirty, after all, as was Gandalf, Strider, Eowyn, et al. Even the actors for most movies who play teenage heroes are in their thirties…the Potter gang being notable exceptions.

I think the time for ageism in fantasy and science fiction is over. While we are all 18 with more or less experience, some of us old farts still buy books, still go to movies, still go to cons, and even buy action figures, models, computer games, and posters.  We don’t have the disposable income of teens–since we are often supporting said fanbase, but we do shell out some ducats on occasion.

And maybe it would help if the young gun movie makers would look beyond their own fear of age and death to see the value of the elder–such as Spock Prime.

13 Responses to “Who wants to read about a middle-aged heroine?”

  1. DingoDogg

    Hi there,
    Can i get a one small pic from your blog?
    Thanks
    DingoDogg

  2. Maven Fairy Godmother

    What picture do you want, and what do you want to do with it?

  3. Barb

    Hi Charlotte – I was reading “Reviving Ophelia – Saving the Selves of Adolesent Girls” and was struck by the observation that in many such fantasy/adventure novels with girls as the protagonist (how many can we list I wonder) – the heroine is usually around the age of 11 – just before adolescence. That is a time in a girl’s life where she is fearless, Artemis like, unencumbered by cultural, familial and social requirements to be beautiful, accommodating…etc. bla bla bla. It seems to me that is the last sanctioned time for women to be so free. I believe women return to that place at midlife – but this time without the cultural blind eye or nod. Recently I spoke with a woman of 60 who described diving into a pool to rescue a puppet or doll, only to find she couldn’t do it alone, and after asking for help found herself emerging from the pool with no doll or puppet, but Pippi Longstockings – now those are the stories that I want to read about! Keep on writing Charlotte!

  4. Charlotte Henley Babb

    Hey Barb! I’m still working through Women Who Run with Wolves, and she talks about how kids, boys and girls, sort of go to sleep at about eleven–their “eyes are hooded though they move about like Mexican jumping beans.” Something about the onset of puberty takes us back to the terrible twos.

    As for chapter books, girls who are 11 or so, want to read about 16 year old heroines, but 7 year olds like to dream of being 11, and 16 year olds like to dream of being 20, as do most authors! I guess what I write is “hen lit.” There has to be an audience of middle aged women who want to be both their own age and powerful…somewhere.

  5. Aaron Wallace

    Great Adult type views and entertainment.-Dating Tips

  6. Kelvin Manion

    Extremely interesting blog post thank you for sharing I have added your blog to my favorites and will check back.

  7. cute baby clothes

    Just bookmarked your site, thanks for sharing!

  8. px90 dvds

    Great site, just bookmarked it. Thanks for sharing

  9. insanity workout dvd

    sorry for the odd post, but I new at this and wanted to say I really like your site.

  10. gucci handbags

    I really like your blog and i respect your work. I’ll be a frequent visitor. How can I subscribe to RSS?

  11. dating fashion advice

    I want to start blogging too, what do you think, which blog platform is good for noob?

  12. free tattoo designs

    Your blog design looks cool. What template did you use ?

  13. Danyel Riessen

    Sorry for the huge review, but I’m really loving the new Zune, and hope this, as well as the excellent reviews some other people have written, will help you decide if it’s the right choice for you.

Leave a Reply

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree